new friendingtopics logo
Monday, October 12th, 2009Those of you who know the background to friendingtopics will know that the first implementation of the site was very straightforward aesthetically.
In order to give the service the quality feel I felt it deserved in the quickest time possible I needed a designer without a backlog. All the designers I usually use had backlogs… Oh oh.
Listening to twist 13 reminded me of 99designs. Without entering into the whole debate about creatives doing unpaid spec work – it seemed like a cost effective, quick, pain free way to get a new identity worked up. So I took 10 minutes to write a spec and fired up my first logo contest.
So how did it go? Well friending topics now has a new logo, so it went well.

The setup process was painless. Certainly quicker than briefing a human designer, involving less caffeine too.
I got over 90 entries to my contest over 7 days. Over half of these came in the last 2 days of the 7 day contest. There is an option to shorten your contest to just 3 days. Assuming these fall during Mon-Fri I’d guess the extra few $s is worth it.
It’s also worth pointing out that of the 90 easily half are duplicates with small changes – some designers drop a few designs in a batch all with a similar theme but subtley different execution. Coming from an agency background this feels a little like sneaking a look at the designers precious ’sketch’ folder when they are getting a coffee. I kinda like it.
Of the 90+ designs there were easily half a dozen really strong options.
A couple of tips if you are using 99designs which might help you to get the best out of the system.
It seems like you get a batch of new entries soon after doing a batch of star ratings. So rate things continually. You can always change your rating later – so if a 3 star grows on you it can be elevated. But failing to rate labels your contest as potentially problematic, deterring designers from spending time on it.
Also, give feedback to designers. I didn’t do enough of this due to a hectic week – and I suspect it would have allowed some of the designers to rework their design to fit my needs more specifically.
Also, be VERY clear in your comments. A lot of the designers don’t have English as a first language so if you are ambiguous you might get the opposite of what you expect. Avoid requests as statements: ‘it might look better in upper rather than mixed’.


